Some rugby losses are hard to explain. This one was easy to explain. The DHL Stormers lost 17 to 13 away to Edinburgh on Friday night, and the simple reason was their lineout. Throw after throw went wrong, and the ball kept ending up in Edinburgh hands.
The Cape side were strong in other areas. They ruled the scrum, defended hard and stayed in the fight until the end. But without clean ball from the touchline, they could not turn that power into points. Here is a plain look at how the game played out.
A tough night at the Hive Stadium
The match was played at the Hive Stadium in Edinburgh. It was the second match of the Vodacom URC season for the Stormers. A week earlier, they had beaten Connacht in Galway, so hopes were high for another good result.
Edinburgh, however, have a strong record against the Stormers at home. They are still unbeaten against the Cape side on Scottish soil. The closest the Stormers have come to a win there is a draw in 2022, on their first visit. It is not an easy place to go.
The Stormers also played both tour matches on artificial pitches, which they like least, and in tricky conditions. That is fair to keep in mind. Still, the surface was not the main story of this game.
The wind and the lineout trouble
A strong wind blew through the stadium, and it made throwing harder. The Stormers played into it in the first half. But the weather cannot explain everything.
Things became messy after starting hooker Venter went off and Vernon Paulo came on. In the first half alone, six Stormers lineouts were lost. Paulo is new to the Stormers set up, so it would be unfair to blame him for it all. At times the communication looked off. Balls went long when the jumpers seemed ready for a short throw.
The wind eased a little after halftime, and the lineout settled for a while. Then the mistakes crept back in.
A lineout is a simple idea. Throw straight, jump together and win the ball. When it works, it gives a team a launch pad for the driving maul. When it fails, you lose the ball and the chance to build pressure. The Stormers have a powerful drive, and they used it well in Galway. In Edinburgh, they only managed that now and then.
The scrum was a different story. The Stormers won that battle easily all night. But a strong scrum cannot fix a weak lineout on its own.
Close at halftime, then a good start to the second half
At the break, the Stormers trailed by just three points. That was a decent effort with the wind in their faces. Their defence was physical, and they carried the ball well when they had it.
Edinburgh felt a little unlucky too. They had a try ruled out late in the half because of a double movement, as the referee saw it. Stormers flyhalf Yaqeen Ahmed also missed an easy kick into the wind.
After the break, the Stormers took charge of territory. Ahmed kicked two penalties, which put them 6 to 3 ahead after 51 minutes. It looked like they were taking control.
Then another poor lineout throw landed in Edinburgh hands. The home side built pressure from it, and replacement prop Paul Hill scored in the 59th minute. Edinburgh were back in front. There may have been a knock in the build up, but the Stormers had still handed over the chance.
Yellow cards and Dayimani’s try
Soon after, Seabelo Senatla was sent to the sin bin for a cynical foul. A few minutes later, Edinburgh’s Freddie Douglas followed him off. His team had been warned many times, as Edinburgh gave away plenty of penalties. The match was back to 14 against 14.
The Stormers then got the reward their scrum deserved. From an advancing attacking scrum, Hacjivah Dayimani controlled the ball and dotted down. He was named man of the match. With Ahmed’s conversion, the Stormers led 13 to 10 with 13 minutes left.
Edinburgh did not panic. Young replacement back Rory McHaffie scored in the corner after the Stormers defence was drawn in and Edinburgh moved the ball wide. The conversion made it 17 to 13. On artificial surfaces, you cannot afford to give the other side momentum. The Stormers learned that the hard way.
The final minutes
Trailing by four, the Stormers needed a try. Fullback Warrick Gelant kicked the ball out inside the Edinburgh 22 late on, which was a strange choice when his team needed to keep the ball alive.
Edinburgh then made their own error. Instead of keeping the ball to run down the clock, they kicked it out of their 22 and gave away a penalty. Ahmed found touch for one last attacking lineout.
This time the jumper was found. But the ball was untidy, as it had been so often that night. Edinburgh took possession and the win. Given how the game went, it was a fitting end.
Match summary
| Team | Tries | Conversions | Penalties | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Edinburgh | Paul Hill, Rory McHaffie | James Grayson (2) | James Grayson (1) | 17 |
| DHL Stormers | Hacjivah Dayimani | Yaqeen Ahmed (1) | Yaqeen Ahmed (2) | 13 |
What this means for the Stormers
The Stormers did leave Scotland with a losing bonus point. That gives them six log points from a tricky tour, which they may have accepted before leaving Cape Town. Even so, this game was a missed opportunity.
The good news is that the fix is simple in theory. Clear calls, accurate throws and better timing would change a lot. The scrum is strong, the defence is tough, and the Stormers showed they can score when they get ball. Physical power means little if the basics are not right.
South African fans can follow fixtures, results and the log on the official United Rugby Championship website.
Final thoughts
This was a close match that came down to one simple thing. Edinburgh did not need to be brilliant. They only had to take the gifts the Stormers kept giving them. The Cape side showed enough in the scrum and in defence to feel confident. If they sort out the lineout, the next result could look very different. It is easy to say, and harder to do, but it is the clear lesson from Edinburgh.
About the Author
